Initial Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue arises because the `negative` argument you are providing does not match any titles in the `titles` list. As a result, `keep_no` becomes an empty list, leading to `set1_no` being empty, which is why you see `OK 1 0`. To fix this, you should ensure that the title specified in the `negative` argument matches exactly with one of the titles in the `titles` list. If the title in the `negative` argument does not match any title, you will need to either correct the title being passed or ensure the titles in the `titles` list are formatted consistently with the input. **Change to fix the issue:** Verify and adjust the `negative` input to match the titles in the `titles` list correctly.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue arises because the `negative` argument you are providing does not match any titles in the `titles` list. As a result, `keep_no` becomes an empty list, leading to `set1_no` being empty, which is why you see `OK 1 0`. To fix this, you should ensure that the title specified in the `negative` argument matches exactly with one of the titles in the `titles` list. If the title in the `negative` argument does not match any title, you will need to either correct the title being passed or ensure the titles in the `titles` list are formatted consistently with the input. **Change to fix the issue:** Verify and adjust the `negative` input to match the titles in the `titles` list correctly. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue lies in how you are handling the `negative` input. Specifically, the string for `negative` appears to be a single title rather than multiple titles separated by `##`. The `negative` string you provided is a single long string, which is not split into separate titles, resulting in `keep_no` being empty since there are no matches found in `titles`. To fix this, ensure that the `negative` input is also formatted with `##` separators if you want to handle multiple titles. For example, if you want to test with two titles, you could change your request to something like: 

1
negative=Title1##Title2
This way, the `negative` variable will split correctly into a list of titles, and you should see `OK 1 1` if both `positive` and `negative` titles match entries in the `titles` list.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue lies in how you are handling the `negative` input. Specifically, the string for `negative` appears to be a single title rather than multiple titles separated by `##`. The `negative` string you provided is a single long string, which is not split into separate titles, resulting in `keep_no` being empty since there are no matches found in `titles`. To fix this, ensure that the `negative` input is also formatted with `##` separators if you want to handle multiple titles. For example, if you want to test with two titles, you could change your request to something like: 

1
negative=Title1##Title2
This way, the `negative` variable will split correctly into a list of titles, and you should see `OK 1 1` if both `positive` and `negative` titles match entries in the `titles` list. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The reason you see `OK 1 0` instead of `OK 1 1` is that the `negative` titles you provided in the request are not matching any titles in the `titles` list. Consequently, the `keep_no` list ends up being empty, resulting in `set1_no` having a length of 0. To fix this, ensure that the titles in the `negative` parameter match exactly (including any whitespace, punctuation, and casing) with the entries in your `titles` list. You can verify the contents of the `titles` list and adjust the input accordingly, or you can add debugging prints to show the contents of `titles` and `negative` to identify mismatches. Here’s a suggested change to help with debugging: 

1
2
print("Titles:", titles)
print("Negative:", negative)
This will help you identify why the title in the negative list isn't matching.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The reason you see `OK 1 0` instead of `OK 1 1` is that the `negative` titles you provided in the request are not matching any titles in the `titles` list. Consequently, the `keep_no` list ends up being empty, resulting in `set1_no` having a length of 0. To fix this, ensure that the titles in the `negative` parameter match exactly (including any whitespace, punctuation, and casing) with the entries in your `titles` list. You can verify the contents of the `titles` list and adjust the input accordingly, or you can add debugging prints to show the contents of `titles` and `negative` to identify mismatches. Here’s a suggested change to help with debugging: 

1
2
print("Titles:", titles)
print("Negative:", negative)
This will help you identify why the title in the negative list isn't matching. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue is that the `negative` argument is not being split correctly due to the way it is passed in the request. The `negative` string contains multiple authors and a title, but it does not have the same delimiter ("##") that you used for the `positive` argument. If you want to ensure that the `negative` titles are recognized correctly, you should check if there are any titles that match exactly or adjust the splitting logic to include proper delimiters. **Change to fix it:** You can modify the way you split the `negative` argument to include a different delimiter or simply pass the negative titles in a similar format as the `positive` titles. For example, if you want to keep the same delimiter, you can adjust your input or change the splitting method to handle the input correctly. For example, if you want to keep the same format, you can ensure that when you call your endpoint, you use a similar delimiter for both `positive` and `negative` titles. If you want to modify the code, you can ensure that the delimiter is consistent: 

1
2
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")  # Ensure you are using the same delimiter as for positive
Alternatively, if you want to allow for different formats, ensure that titles are split correctly based on their structure.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue is that the `negative` argument is not being split correctly due to the way it is passed in the request. The `negative` string contains multiple authors and a title, but it does not have the same delimiter ("##") that you used for the `positive` argument. If you want to ensure that the `negative` titles are recognized correctly, you should check if there are any titles that match exactly or adjust the splitting logic to include proper delimiters. **Change to fix it:** You can modify the way you split the `negative` argument to include a different delimiter or simply pass the negative titles in a similar format as the `positive` titles. For example, if you want to keep the same delimiter, you can adjust your input or change the splitting method to handle the input correctly. For example, if you want to keep the same format, you can ensure that when you call your endpoint, you use a similar delimiter for both `positive` and `negative` titles. If you want to modify the code, you can ensure that the delimiter is consistent: 

1
2
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")  # Ensure you are using the same delimiter as for positive
Alternatively, if you want to allow for different formats, ensure that titles are split correctly based on their structure. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails. The student's answer addresses the issue with the splitting logic of the `negative` argument and suggests a solution to ensure that the delimiter is consistent. However, it does not mention anything about an extra curly brace `}` in the input, which was the specific reason given for why the code was incorrect. Therefore, the student's answer does not directly address the given reason for the code's incorrectness.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
I see 
1
2
3
args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue arises from how you're checking for matches between the `titles` and the `negative` list. The `negative` string contains multiple authors and the title, but your code attempts to check if the entire `negative` string exists as a title in the `titles` list. Since `titles` likely contains separate titles, the entire `negative` string won't match any specific title. **Change needed**: Instead of checking if `x` (which is the entire `negative` string) exists in `titles`, you should split the `negative` string into individual titles (if applicable) and then check for matches. **Modified code snippet**: 

1
keep_no = [i for i, x in enumerate(titles) if any(title in x for title in negative)]
This change ensures that you check if any title from the `negative` list is present in the `titles`, allowing for more flexible matching.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue arises from how you're checking for matches between the `titles` and the `negative` list. The `negative` string contains multiple authors and the title, but your code attempts to check if the entire `negative` string exists as a title in the `titles` list. Since `titles` likely contains separate titles, the entire `negative` string won't match any specific title. **Change needed**: Instead of checking if `x` (which is the entire `negative` string) exists in `titles`, you should split the `negative` string into individual titles (if applicable) and then check for matches. **Modified code snippet**: 

1
keep_no = [i for i, x in enumerate(titles) if any(title in x for title in negative)]
This change ensures that you check if any title from the `negative` list is present in the `titles`, allowing for more flexible matching. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False