Initial Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
LLM Generation
Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
Output
The issue is likely due to extra spaces in the split strings within the `negative` list.
**Explanation:**
You split the `positive` and `negative` strings using "##" as the delimiter. However, if there are extra spaces around the title in the `negative` string, the resulting split elements won't match the titles in the `titles` list exactly.
**Fix:**
Strip any leading/trailing whitespace from the split titles before comparing them.
| negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = [x.strip() for x in negative.split("##")] # Strip whitespace here
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
|
By adding `.strip()` to each element in the `negative` list after splitting, you ensure that any extra spaces are removed, allowing for accurate comparison with the `titles` list.
LLM Generation
Query
I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that?
The issue is likely due to extra spaces in the split strings within the `negative` list.
**Explanation:**
You split the `positive` and `negative` strings using "##" as the delimiter. However, if there are extra spaces around the title in the `negative` string, the resulting split elements won't match the titles in the `titles` list exactly.
**Fix:**
Strip any leading/trailing whitespace from the split titles before comparing them.
| negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = [x.strip() for x in negative.split("##")] # Strip whitespace here
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
|
By adding `.strip()` to each element in the `negative` list after splitting, you ensure that any extra spaces are removed, allowing for accurate comparison with the `titles` list.
Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.
Output
The student fails.
Substring Evaluation
Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False
Initial Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
LLM Generation
Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
Output
The issue is likely due to an **exact string mismatch** between the provided titles in the 'negative' argument and the titles present in the `titles` list.
**The Fix:** Implement a case-insensitive or substring matching mechanism when comparing titles.
For example, instead of:
| keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
|
Use:
| keep_no = [i for i, x in enumerate(titles) if any(n.lower() in x.lower() for n in negative)]
|
This change converts both the titles in `titles` and `negative` to lowercase before comparison and uses `any()` to check if any part of a title from `negative` is present in a title from `titles`. This accounts for potential case mismatches or if the provided titles are not full matches.
LLM Generation
Query
I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that?
The issue is likely due to an **exact string mismatch** between the provided titles in the 'negative' argument and the titles present in the `titles` list.
**The Fix:** Implement a case-insensitive or substring matching mechanism when comparing titles.
For example, instead of:
| keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
|
Use:
| keep_no = [i for i, x in enumerate(titles) if any(n.lower() in x.lower() for n in negative)]
|
This change converts both the titles in `titles` and `negative` to lowercase before comparison and uses `any()` to check if any part of a title from `negative` is present in a title from `titles`. This accounts for potential case mismatches or if the provided titles are not full matches.
Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.
Output
The student fails.
Substring Evaluation
Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False
Initial Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
LLM Generation
Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
Output
The issue is likely due to extra spaces around the "##" delimiter in your input strings.
**Reason:**
When you split the 'positive' and 'negative' strings using "##" as the delimiter, you are not accounting for potential spaces before or after the "##". This means that if there are extra spaces, they will be included as part of the split items, leading to mismatches when comparing with `titles`.
**Fix:**
To fix this, split the strings using `"##"` as the delimiter (with spaces) instead of just `"##"`. This will ensure that any extra spaces around the delimiter are ignored.
**Change:**
Replace these lines:
| positive = positive.split("##")
negative = negative.split("##")
|
with these:
| positive = positive.split(" ## ")
negative = negative.split(" ## ")
|
This change will split the strings correctly, even if there are extra spaces around the "##" delimiter.
LLM Generation
Query
I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that?
The issue is likely due to extra spaces around the "##" delimiter in your input strings.
**Reason:**
When you split the 'positive' and 'negative' strings using "##" as the delimiter, you are not accounting for potential spaces before or after the "##". This means that if there are extra spaces, they will be included as part of the split items, leading to mismatches when comparing with `titles`.
**Fix:**
To fix this, split the strings using `"##"` as the delimiter (with spaces) instead of just `"##"`. This will ensure that any extra spaces around the delimiter are ignored.
**Change:**
Replace these lines:
| positive = positive.split("##")
negative = negative.split("##")
|
with these:
| positive = positive.split(" ## ")
negative = negative.split(" ## ")
|
This change will split the strings correctly, even if there are extra spaces around the "##" delimiter.
Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.
Output
The student fails.
Substring Evaluation
Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False
Initial Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
LLM Generation
Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
Output
The issue is likely due to whitespace discrepancies between the `titles` list and the strings passed in the `negative` argument.
**Reason:** The code splits the `positive` and `negative` strings by "##", but the error message suggests you are passing the entire title (including "Title:", "Authors:", and potentially extra spaces) as a single item. If the `titles` list doesn't have the exact same formatting (including spaces), the `in` operator within the list comprehension won't find a match for the negative title.
**Fix:** To fix this, you should ensure consistent formatting between the `titles` list and the strings passed in the request arguments. One way to do this is by stripping whitespace and standardizing the format before comparison:
| keep_no = [i for i, x in enumerate(titles) if x.strip() == y.strip() for y in negative]
|
This modification strips leading and trailing whitespace from both the elements in `titles` and the strings in `negative` during the comparison, making the matching more robust to formatting variations.
LLM Generation
Query
I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that?
The issue is likely due to whitespace discrepancies between the `titles` list and the strings passed in the `negative` argument.
**Reason:** The code splits the `positive` and `negative` strings by "##", but the error message suggests you are passing the entire title (including "Title:", "Authors:", and potentially extra spaces) as a single item. If the `titles` list doesn't have the exact same formatting (including spaces), the `in` operator within the list comprehension won't find a match for the negative title.
**Fix:** To fix this, you should ensure consistent formatting between the `titles` list and the strings passed in the request arguments. One way to do this is by stripping whitespace and standardizing the format before comparison:
| keep_no = [i for i, x in enumerate(titles) if x.strip() == y.strip() for y in negative]
|
This modification strips leading and trailing whitespace from both the elements in `titles` and the strings in `negative` during the comparison, making the matching more robust to formatting variations.
Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.
Output
The student fails.
Substring Evaluation
Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False
Initial Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
LLM Generation
Query
Why isn't this working
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16 | @app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
print('args',request.args)
positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
positive = positive.split("##")
negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
negative = negative.split("##")
keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]
keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
set1_no = emb[keep_no]
print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))
|
I see
| args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0
|
Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.
Output
The issue is likely due to whitespace differences in how you split the titles versus how they are stored in `titles`.
**Problem:** You split the `positive` and `negative` strings using `##` as the delimiter. However, the titles in the `titles` list might not be delimited by `##` or might have extra spaces around the delimiter.
**Solution:** Ensure consistent delimiters and handle potential whitespace issues. Instead of relying on `##` for splitting, try splitting by newline characters (`\n`) and stripping any leading/trailing whitespace from each title.
**Change:**
| positive = [x.strip() for x in positive.split("\n")]
negative = [x.strip() for x in negative.split("\n")]
|
This modification splits the strings by newline characters and removes any extra spaces, ensuring that the titles in `positive` and `negative` match the format in the `titles` list.
LLM Generation
Query
I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that?
The issue is likely due to whitespace differences in how you split the titles versus how they are stored in `titles`.
**Problem:** You split the `positive` and `negative` strings using `##` as the delimiter. However, the titles in the `titles` list might not be delimited by `##` or might have extra spaces around the delimiter.
**Solution:** Ensure consistent delimiters and handle potential whitespace issues. Instead of relying on `##` for splitting, try splitting by newline characters (`\n`) and stripping any leading/trailing whitespace from each title.
**Change:**
| positive = [x.strip() for x in positive.split("\n")]
negative = [x.strip() for x in negative.split("\n")]
|
This modification splits the strings by newline characters and removes any extra spaces, ensuring that the titles in `positive` and `negative` match the format in the `titles` list.
Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.
Output
The student fails.
Substring Evaluation
Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False