Initial Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue is that the titles in your list `titles` likely do not exactly match the titles in the input, which prevents matching the negative example. In the input, the negative title contains curly braces `}` at the end, which might not be present in your `titles` list. To fix this, you could modify the comparison to strip or clean the titles before matching, such as:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x.strip('{}') in negative[0].strip('{}')]

This change would ensure that the matching is more flexible and can handle slight differences in formatting.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue is that the titles in your list `titles` likely do not exactly match the titles in the input, which prevents matching the negative example. In the input, the negative title contains curly braces `}` at the end, which might not be present in your `titles` list. To fix this, you could modify the comparison to strip or clean the titles before matching, such as:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x.strip('{}') in negative[0].strip('{}')]

This change would ensure that the matching is more flexible and can handle slight differences in formatting. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue is that the negative titles might not exactly match the titles in your `titles` list due to the trailing `}` character in the example negative input. To fix this, you could strip any trailing `}` from the negative titles before comparing:

negative = request.args.get('negative', '').rstrip('}').split("##")

This will remove the trailing `}` and allow the negative title to match the titles in your `titles` list, likely resulting in the `OK 1 1` output you're expecting.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue is that the negative titles might not exactly match the titles in your `titles` list due to the trailing `}` character in the example negative input. To fix this, you could strip any trailing `}` from the negative titles before comparing:

negative = request.args.get('negative', '').rstrip('}').split("##")

This will remove the trailing `}` and allow the negative title to match the titles in your `titles` list, likely resulting in the `OK 1 1` output you're expecting. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student passes.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: True

Initial Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The reason is that the `titles` list does not contain the full titles with "Title:" and "Authors:" prefixes. To fix this, modify the comparison to use the full string or strip these prefixes when comparing:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]

This would ensure that the full title is matched correctly, allowing both the positive and negative lists to find their respective matches in the `titles` list.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The reason is that the `titles` list does not contain the full titles with "Title:" and "Authors:" prefixes. To fix this, modify the comparison to use the full string or strip these prefixes when comparing:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]

This would ensure that the full title is matched correctly, allowing both the positive and negative lists to find their respective matches in the `titles` list. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The reason the negative list is not matching is likely due to the full string matching. In your current code, `x in titles` requires an exact match, but the negative example you showed has a slightly different format compared to the titles in your `titles` list. To fix this, you could modify the condition to do a more flexible match, such as using `in` with a substring check or stripping out unnecessary parts before comparing:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative[0].split('Title:')[1].split('Authors:')[0].strip()]

This change would extract just the title part from the negative input and do a more lenient match against the titles in your list.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The reason the negative list is not matching is likely due to the full string matching. In your current code, `x in titles` requires an exact match, but the negative example you showed has a slightly different format compared to the titles in your `titles` list. To fix this, you could modify the condition to do a more flexible match, such as using `in` with a substring check or stripping out unnecessary parts before comparing:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative[0].split('Title:')[1].split('Authors:')[0].strip()]

This change would extract just the title part from the negative input and do a more lenient match against the titles in your list. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

LLM Generation

Query

Why isn't this working

@app.route('/getsimilar', methods=['GET'])
def getsimilar():
    print('args',request.args)
    positive = request.args.get('positive', '')
    positive = positive.split("##")

    negative = request.args.get('negative', '')
    negative = negative.split("##")

    keep_yes = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in positive]
    set1_yes = emb[keep_yes]

    keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if x in negative]
    set1_no = emb[keep_no]

    print("OK", len(set1_yes), len(set1_no))

I see

args ImmutableMultiDict([('positive', 'Title: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Neural Networks
Authors: Nicholas Carlini; David Wagner'), ('negative', 'Title: On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness Authors: Nicholas Carlini; Anish Athalye; Nicolas Papernot; Wieland Brendel; Jonas Rauber; Dimitris Tsipras; Ian Goodfellow; Aleksander Madry; Alexey Kurakin}')])
OK 1 0

Why don't I see OK 1 1? Instead it just says OK 1 0. List exactly one reason explaining what's wrong and what one change would fix it.

Output

The issue is that the titles in the `titles` list likely do not exactly match the input titles, which causes the list comprehension for `keep_no` to return an empty list. One change to fix this would be to use more flexible matching, such as stripping whitespace or using a substring match, instead of an exact match. For example:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if any(neg_title in x for neg_title in negative)]

This would allow partial matching of titles, which seems more robust given the format of the input titles.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because the input contains an extra curly brace }". Does this student answer say that? The issue is that the titles in the `titles` list likely do not exactly match the input titles, which causes the list comprehension for `keep_no` to return an empty list. One change to fix this would be to use more flexible matching, such as stripping whitespace or using a substring match, instead of an exact match. For example:

keep_no = [i for i,x in enumerate(titles) if any(neg_title in x for neg_title in negative)]

This would allow partial matching of titles, which seems more robust given the format of the input titles. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False