Initial Query

Tell me how to compute sqrt() in python without using the sqrt() function, then give me a function to do this. I want the answer as precise as possible. Call the function my_sqrt()..

LLM Generation

Query

Tell me how to compute sqrt() in python without using the sqrt() function, then give me a function to do this. I want the answer as precise as possible. Call the function my_sqrt()..

Output

Okay, let's break down how to compute a square root numerically and then implement it in Python. **Method: The Babylonian Method (a specific case of Newton-Raphson)** This is an ancient and efficient iterative method to approximate square roots. Here's the idea: 1. **Goal:** Find a number `y` such that `y * y = x` (or `y^2 = x`). 2. **Guess:** Start with an initial guess for the square root, let's call it `guess`. A simple starting guess could be `x` itself, or `x / 2`. 3. **Improve the Guess:** If `guess` is the actual square root, then `x / guess` would also be equal to `guess`. * If our `guess` is too *large*, then `x / guess` will be too *small*. * If our `guess` is too *small*, then `x / guess` will be too *large*. * In either case, the *true* square root lies somewhere between `guess` and `x / guess`. 4. **New Guess:** A good way to get a better guess is to average the current `guess` and `x / guess`. So, the next guess becomes: `next_guess = (guess + x / guess) / 2` 5. **Repeat:** Keep applying step 4, using the `next_guess` as the new `guess` for the subsequent iteration. 6. **Stop:** Continue iterating until the guess stops changing significantly (or, for maximum precision with floating-point numbers, until the guess stops changing *at all* within the limits of float precision). **Handling Edge Cases:** * **Negative Numbers:** The square root of a negative number is imaginary. Standard functions usually raise an error or return `NaN` (Not a Number). We should raise a `ValueError`. * **Zero:** The square root of 0 is 0. We can handle this directly. **Achieving Precision:** Python uses floating-point numbers (usually IEEE 754 double-precision). These numbers have a finite precision. The Babylonian method converges very quickly. By repeating the iteration until the calculated `next_guess` is *exactly equal* to the previous `guess` (due to floating-point limitations), we effectively get the most precise answer possible within standard float representation. **Python Function Implementation** 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
import sys

def my_sqrt(x):
  """
  Computes the square root of a non-negative number using the Babylonian method.

  Args:
    x: The number (must be non-negative) for which to compute the square root.

  Returns:
    The floating-point approximation of the square root of x.

  Raises:
    ValueError: If x is negative.
  """
  if x < 0:
    raise ValueError("Cannot compute square root of a negative number")
  if x == 0:
    return 0.0 # The square root of 0 is 0

  # Ensure x is treated as a float for division precision
  x = float(x)

  # Start with an initial guess (x itself is a safe choice, though others exist)
  guess = x

  # Use machine epsilon for a potential alternative stopping condition,
  # but comparing the guess directly often works best for max float precision.
  # epsilon = sys.float_info.epsilon

  while True:
    next_guess = 0.5 * (guess + x / guess)

    # Check if the guess has converged (stopped changing)
    if guess == next_guess:
        break # Reached the limit of float precision

    # Alternative check (less common for max precision, needs tolerance):
    # if abs(guess - next_guess) < epsilon * guess:
    #    break

    guess = next_guess

  return guess

# --- Example Usage ---
import math

numbers_to_test = [0, 1, 2, 4, 9, 10, 100, 99, 0.5, 1e-10, 1e10, 12345.6789]

print("Number\t\tmy_sqrt()\t\tmath.sqrt()\t\tDifference")
print("-" * 70)

for num in numbers_to_test:
  my_result = my_sqrt(num)
  math_result = math.sqrt(num)
  diff = abs(my_result - math_result)
  print(f"{num:<15}\t{my_result:<20}\t{math_result:<20}\t{diff:<15e}")

# Example of handling negative input
try:
  my_sqrt(-5)
except ValueError as e:
  print(f"\nError testing negative number: {e}")
**Explanation of the Code:** 1. **`import sys`**: Although not strictly used in the final version's stopping condition, `sys.float_info.epsilon` represents the smallest difference between 1.0 and the next representable float, useful if you wanted a tolerance-based stop. 2. **`def my_sqrt(x):`**: Defines the function. 3. **Error Handling**: Checks if `x` is negative and raises a `ValueError` if it is. 4. **Base Case**: Checks if `x` is 0 and returns `0.0` immediately. 5. **`x = float(x)`**: Ensures `x` is a float to guarantee floating-point division later. 6. **`guess = x`**: Sets the initial guess. `x/2` or `1.0` are other common starting points, but `x` works well. 7. **`while True:`**: Starts an infinite loop that will be broken internally. 8. **`next_guess = 0.5 * (guess + x / guess)`**: Implements the core Babylonian method formula. Using `0.5 * ...` is sometimes slightly more efficient than `/ 2.0`. 9. **`if guess == next_guess:`**: This is the key stopping condition. When the iterative formula produces a result that is identical (within floating-point representation) to the input guess, it means we've converged as much as possible. 10. **`break`**: Exits the loop once converged. 11. **`guess = next_guess`**: Updates the guess for the next iteration. 12. **`return guess`**: Returns the final, converged approximation of the square root. 13. **Example Usage**: The code demonstrates how to use the function and compares its output to the standard `math.sqrt()` function, showing the difference (which should be zero or extremely small).

Extract Code

I extracted the following code from that output: 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
import sys

def my_sqrt(x):
  """
  Computes the square root of a non-negative number using the Babylonian method.

  Args:
    x: The number (must be non-negative) for which to compute the square root.

  Returns:
    The floating-point approximation of the square root of x.

  Raises:
    ValueError: If x is negative.
  """
  if x < 0:
    raise ValueError("Cannot compute square root of a negative number")
  if x == 0:
    return 0.0 # The square root of 0 is 0

  # Ensure x is treated as a float for division precision
  x = float(x)

  # Start with an initial guess (x itself is a safe choice, though others exist)
  guess = x

  # Use machine epsilon for a potential alternative stopping condition,
  # but comparing the guess directly often works best for max float precision.
  # epsilon = sys.float_info.epsilon

  while True:
    next_guess = 0.5 * (guess + x / guess)

    # Check if the guess has converged (stopped changing)
    if guess == next_guess:
        break # Reached the limit of float precision

    # Alternative check (less common for max precision, needs tolerance):
    # if abs(guess - next_guess) < epsilon * guess:
    #    break

    guess = next_guess

  return guess

# --- Example Usage ---
import math

numbers_to_test = [0, 1, 2, 4, 9, 10, 100, 99, 0.5, 1e-10, 1e10, 12345.6789]

print("Number\t\tmy_sqrt()\t\tmath.sqrt()\t\tDifference")
print("-" * 70)

for num in numbers_to_test:
  my_result = my_sqrt(num)
  math_result = math.sqrt(num)
  diff = abs(my_result - math_result)
  print(f"{num:<15}\t{my_result:<20}\t{math_result:<20}\t{diff:<15e}")

# Example of handling negative input
try:
  my_sqrt(-5)
except ValueError as e:
  print(f"\nError testing negative number: {e}")

Check if all of the following conditions are true:

Run Code Interpreter

Running the following program: 

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
import sys

def my_sqrt(x):
  """
  Computes the square root of a non-negative number using the Babylonian method.

  Args:
    x: The number (must be non-negative) for which to compute the square root.

  Returns:
    The floating-point approximation of the square root of x.

  Raises:
    ValueError: If x is negative.
  """
  if x < 0:
    raise ValueError("Cannot compute square root of a negative number")
  if x == 0:
    return 0.0 # The square root of 0 is 0

  # Ensure x is treated as a float for division precision
  x = float(x)

  # Start with an initial guess (x itself is a safe choice, though others exist)
  guess = x

  # Use machine epsilon for a potential alternative stopping condition,
  # but comparing the guess directly often works best for max float precision.
  # epsilon = sys.float_info.epsilon

  while True:
    next_guess = 0.5 * (guess + x / guess)

    # Check if the guess has converged (stopped changing)
    if guess == next_guess:
        break # Reached the limit of float precision

    # Alternative check (less common for max precision, needs tolerance):
    # if abs(guess - next_guess) < epsilon * guess:
    #    break

    guess = next_guess

  return guess

# --- Example Usage ---
import math

numbers_to_test = [0, 1, 2, 4, 9, 10, 100, 99, 0.5, 1e-10, 1e10, 12345.6789]

print("Number\t\tmy_sqrt()\t\tmath.sqrt()\t\tDifference")
print("-" * 70)

for num in numbers_to_test:
  my_result = my_sqrt(num)
  math_result = math.sqrt(num)
  diff = abs(my_result - math_result)
  print(f"{num:<15}\t{my_result:<20}\t{math_result:<20}\t{diff:<15e}")

# Example of handling negative input
try:
  my_sqrt(-5)
except ValueError as e:
  print(f"\nError testing negative number: {e}")





answer = round(my_sqrt(12345), 1)
expected = 111.1
assert answer == expected, f'Wrong answer; got {answer} instead of {expected}'
print('All tests passed')
And got the output: 
 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Number      my_sqrt()       math.sqrt()     Difference</p>
<hr />
<p>0               0.0                     0.0                     0.000000e+00 <br />
1               1.0                     1.0                     0.000000e+00 <br />
2               1.414213562373095       1.4142135623730951      2.220446e-16 <br />
4               2.0                     2.0                     0.000000e+00 <br />
9               3.0                     3.0                     0.000000e+00 <br />
10              3.162277660168379       3.1622776601683795      4.440892e-16 <br />
100             10.0                    10.0                    0.000000e+00 <br />
99              9.9498743710662         9.9498743710662         0.000000e+00 <br />
0.5             0.7071067811865475      0.7071067811865476      1.110223e-16 <br />
1e-10           9.999999999999999e-06   1e-05                   1.694066e-21 <br />
10000000000.0   100000.0                100000.0                0.000000e+00 <br />
12345.6789      111.11111060555555      111.11111060555555      0.000000e+00 <br />
Error testing negative number: Cannot compute square root of a negative number
All tests passed

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string All tests passed: True

LLM Generation

Query

Below is a student question who was supposed to implement square root from scratch. Did they cheat and just call sqrt directly? Think out loud, then finally answer either 'Yes they cheated' or 'No they did not cheat' import sys def my_sqrt(x): """ Computes the square root of a non-negative number using the Babylonian method. Args: x: The number (must be non-negative) for which to compute the square root. Returns: The floating-point approximation of the square root of x. Raises: ValueError: If x is negative. """ if x < 0: raise ValueError("Cannot compute square root of a negative number") if x == 0: return 0.0 # The square root of 0 is 0 # Ensure x is treated as a float for division precision x = float(x) # Start with an initial guess (x itself is a safe choice, though others exist) guess = x # Use machine epsilon for a potential alternative stopping condition, # but comparing the guess directly often works best for max float precision. # epsilon = sys.float_info.epsilon while True: next_guess = 0.5 * (guess + x / guess) # Check if the guess has converged (stopped changing) if guess == next_guess: break # Reached the limit of float precision # Alternative check (less common for max precision, needs tolerance): # if abs(guess - next_guess) < epsilon * guess: # break guess = next_guess return guess # --- Example Usage --- import math numbers_to_test = [0, 1, 2, 4, 9, 10, 100, 99, 0.5, 1e-10, 1e10, 12345.6789] print("Number\t\tmy_sqrt()\t\tmath.sqrt()\t\tDifference") print("-" * 70) for num in numbers_to_test: my_result = my_sqrt(num) math_result = math.sqrt(num) diff = abs(my_result - math_result) print(f"{num:<15}\t{my_result:<20}\t{math_result:<20}\t{diff:<15e}") # Example of handling negative input try: my_sqrt(-5) except ValueError as e: print(f"\nError testing negative number: {e}")

Output

Let's analyze the provided code to determine if the student cheated by directly calling the `sqrt` function from a library instead of implementing it from scratch. 1. **Function Definition**: The student defines a function `my_sqrt(x)` that is intended to compute the square root of a non-negative number using the Babylonian method (also known as Heron's method). This is a well-known iterative algorithm for approximating square roots. 2. **Input Validation**: The function checks if `x` is negative and raises a `ValueError` if so. This is a standard practice to handle invalid inputs. 3. **Initial Guess**: The function starts with an initial guess for the square root, which is simply the number `x` itself. This is a common choice for the initial guess in the Babylonian method. 4. **Iterative Process**: The function uses a `while True` loop to iteratively improve the guess for the square root. In each iteration, it calculates a new guess using the formula: \[ \text{next\_guess} = 0.5 \times (\text{guess} + \frac{x}{\text{guess}}) \] This is the core of the Babylonian method. 5. **Convergence Check**: The loop continues until the guess does not change between iterations, indicating convergence. This is checked with `if guess == next_guess: break`. 6. **Return Value**: Once convergence is achieved, the function returns the final guess as the approximate square root. 7. **Comparison with `math.sqrt`**: The script includes a section that compares the results of `my_sqrt` with Python's built-in `math.sqrt` function for various test numbers. This is a reasonable way to validate the implementation. 8. **Handling Negative Input**: The script also demonstrates handling of negative input by catching the `ValueError`. **Conclusion**: The student has implemented the square root function using the Babylonian method, which is a legitimate algorithm for this purpose. The code does not call `math.sqrt` within the `my_sqrt` function itself; it only uses `math.sqrt` outside the function to compare results. This comparison is a valid way to test the accuracy of the implementation. Therefore, the student did not cheat by directly calling `sqrt` from a library within their implementation. **Final Answer**: No they did not cheat.

Check this condition is not true:

Check if any of the following conditions are true:

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string es, they cheated: False

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string es they cheated: False

Final Answer: False

Final Answer: True

Final Answer: True