Initial Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

LLM Generation

Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

Output

The `out.append(hist)` line adds the *entire* history of the sub-operation `arg` as a single element to the list `out`. This nests histories instead of concatenating them, leading to an incorrect overall history representation. It should use `out.extend(hist)` to correctly combine the histories.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because because the code uses append instead of extend". Does this student answer say that? Giving multiple answers is okay as long as it also says somewhere that the code should replace the append with extend. The `out.append(hist)` line adds the *entire* history of the sub-operation `arg` as a single element to the list `out`. This nests histories instead of concatenating them, leading to an incorrect overall history representation. It should use `out.extend(hist)` to correctly combine the histories. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student passes.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: True

Initial Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

LLM Generation

Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

Output

The function uses `+` to combine lists, which results in nested lists instead of a flat list of operations and their histories. For example, `[(how, make_op(config))] + out` will append the *list* `out` to the list containing `(how, make_op(config))`, rather than appending the *elements* of `out`.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because because the code uses append instead of extend". Does this student answer say that? Giving multiple answers is okay as long as it also says somewhere that the code should replace the append with extend. The function uses `+` to combine lists, which results in nested lists instead of a flat list of operations and their histories. For example, `[(how, make_op(config))] + out` will append the *list* `out` to the list containing `(how, make_op(config))`, rather than appending the *elements* of `out`. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

LLM Generation

Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

Output

The `out.append(hist)` adds the entire nested list `hist` as a single element to `out`, rather than extending `out` with the elements of `hist`. This creates an unintended nested list structure instead of a flat list of (operation, function) tuples.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because because the code uses append instead of extend". Does this student answer say that? Giving multiple answers is okay as long as it also says somewhere that the code should replace the append with extend. The `out.append(hist)` adds the entire nested list `hist` as a single element to `out`, rather than extending `out` with the elements of `hist`. This creates an unintended nested list structure instead of a flat list of (operation, function) tuples. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student passes.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: True

Initial Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

LLM Generation

Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

Output

The function uses `+` to combine lists of histories. This results in a flattened list instead of a nested list to represent the hierarchical structure of the operations. It should use `append` or list extension within a loop to preserve the nested structure.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because because the code uses append instead of extend". Does this student answer say that? Giving multiple answers is okay as long as it also says somewhere that the code should replace the append with extend. The function uses `+` to combine lists of histories. This results in a flattened list instead of a nested list to represent the hierarchical structure of the operations. It should use `append` or list extension within a loop to preserve the nested structure. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False

Initial Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

LLM Generation

Query

Why won't this function work as expected? List exactly one reason.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
def make_op_with_history(config):
    how = config[0]
    args = config[1:]

    if how.split()[0] == 'dot_from_papers':
        return [(how, make_op(config))]
    if how.split()[0] in ['const_add', 'const_mul']:
        return [(how, make_op(config))] + make_op_with_history(config[1])
    out = []
    for arg in args:
        hist = make_op_with_history(arg)
        out.append(hist)
    return [(how, make_op(config))] + out

Output

The function uses `+` to combine lists, which results in nested lists instead of a flat list of operations and their histories when dealing with operations that have multiple arguments. The `out.append(hist)` adds the entire history of a sub-operation as a single element within `out`, creating a nested structure.

LLM Generation

Query

I asked a question about why some code was incorrect. The answer is "because because the code uses append instead of extend". Does this student answer say that? Giving multiple answers is okay as long as it also says somewhere that the code should replace the append with extend. The function uses `+` to combine lists, which results in nested lists instead of a flat list of operations and their histories when dealing with operations that have multiple arguments. The `out.append(hist)` adds the entire history of a sub-operation as a single element within `out`, creating a nested structure. Answer either 'The student passes' or 'The student fails'.

Output

The student fails.

Substring Evaluation

Testing if the previous output contains the string student passes: False